PASTORAL PLANNING CLUSTER TASK FORCE RECOMMENDATION REPORT for 2012

Please attach additional pages if more space is needed.

 

Deanery:           Rockingham              Dean: Very Rev. Frederick J. Pennett, Jr., V.F.

Cluster:             16

Facilitator(s):                Paul J. Ashton, Psy.D., D.Min.

Recorder:                     Mrs. Joyce Lee

Priest Allocation:           2 Diocesan Priests and 2 Religious (Jesuits)

 

Cluster Task Force Members (Name and Parish):

 

Rev. Robert C. Guillemette                          Saint Patrick

Mr. James B. Hogan                                     Saint Patrick

Mrs. M. Gael Ouellette                                Saint Patrick

Rev. Paul F. Ruzzo                                         Mary, Queen of Peace

Mrs. Donna Sytek                                         Mary, Queen of Peace

Mrs. Mary Giordano                                     Mary, Queen of Peace

Rev. John W. Michalowski, S.J.                   Saint Joseph

Mr. Shawn McDonough                                Saint Joseph

Mrs. Claire W. Simensen                              Saint Joseph

Rev. Msgr. Donald Gilbert                           Saint Matthew

Mrs. Ginny Dandreta                                    Saint Matthew

Mrs. Betty Epperson                                     Saint Matthew

 

Parishes represented in the Cluster Task Force (CTF):

 Parish: Saint Patrick                                       Location:  Pelham  

 Parish: Saint Matthew                                    Location:  Windham

 Parish: Mary, Queen of Peace                      Location:  Salem

 Parish: Saint Joseph                                       Location:  Salem

 

Dates and locations of Listening Sessions:

Date:    Sunday            6 May      2007           Location:  Saint Matthew, Windham

Date:    Monday          18 June                       Location:  Mary, Queen of Peace, Salem

 

Dates and locations of Working Sessions:

Date:    Tuesday          1 May                         Location:  Saint Patrick, Pelham       

Date:    Wednesday     16 May                       Location:  Saint Joseph, Salem          

Date:    Monday          21 May                       Location:  Mary, Queen of Peace, Salem

Date:    Sunday            27 May                       Location:  Saint Patrick, Pelham

Date:    Sunday            3 June                         Location:  Mary, Queen of Peace, Salem

Date:    Sunday            10 June                       Location:  Saint Joseph, Salem

 

 

 

Description of the process used by the CTF in arriving at consensus:

 

In coming together as a task force there was an almost immediate sense that the group was cohesive and cared greatly not only for their own parish, but for the deanery parishes and diocesan church as a whole.  The commitment and cumulative ministry experience was an overwhelming foundation which buttressed each conversation of local church.  Not only were individuals articulate and knowledgeable about their particular parish and history, their keen sense of the Church universal was woven throughout conversations and deliberations. Theological and other related pastoral and educational ministerial experience made for a smooth flowing, and open dialogue.  A deep sense of prayerful spirituality under girded our process.  We were always made aware of the full presence of God and a need for solidarity for the poor and marginalized.  Even in areas of discussion that became heated, respect was paramount.

From the initial meeting each task force member articulated their affective approach and history of their parish.  Although there might have been some resistance and desire to begin immediate scenario formulation, much time was spent sharing the gifts and raising the highlights of each parish community.  As well, each parish was able to present the difficulties undergone in recent history.

Significant time was spent clarifying the role that the Society of Jesus would play in the configuration for 2012. This is reflected clearly in the minutes of our meetings.

Through working sessions led by the facilitator of appreciative inquiry, mutual and open dialogue, prayer, shared feelings, thoughts, dreams and ideals, the task force was able to brainstorm scenarios and vision for the future.  Through guided appreciative inquiry, the CTF built on shared goodness thus fostering positive relationships which enhanced the system’s capacity for collaboration, consensus and change. We discovered and identified the organizational processes that worked well, we dreamed and envisioned the processes that might work well in the future, we designed, planned and prioritized processes that might work and we delivered a possible destiny for implementation and execution.

Through the same process of open conversation and discussion, the task force formed and ultimately eliminated various scenarios for the future. 

When left with two major choices involving Saint Joseph Parish twinning or merging with either Mary, Queen of Peace or Saint Matthew Parish, the task force turned over to the Jesuits the process of discernment as to which direction they felt best to pursue.  The Jesuits took two weeks to discern their decision.

 

 

 

 

Recommendation to the Dean and LRPC for 2012 ministry coverage:

We recommend that Mary, Queen of Peace and St. Joseph be served by two Jesuits and be merged in two steps. In Phase I, Mary, Queen of Peace and St. Joseph would be twinned for a year or two. This would allow for an integration of programs and committees. In Phase II, the parishes would merge into a new parish with two worship sites. In 2006, the two parishes had an average attendance of 2523 and served 3795 households with population of some 10,174 persons. In 2007, both parishes added members both in their registry and in their numbers at Sunday Masses. Because of growth in the area and because of the religious needs of St. Joseph Regional School, it is important that both worship spaces be preserved.

 

We also recommend that Saint Patrick be maintained as it presently exists to be pastored by one diocesan priest.


Finally, we recommend that Saint Matthew be maintained as it presently exists to be pastored by one diocesan priest.

 

Rationale for the recommendation:

 

The southern tier of the diocese, as it has come to be called and known, is the fastest growing geographical region both in population and economy.  It was difficult, therefore, for the CTF to accept the reality that a diminished clergy would be a part of any rationale to serve this fast growing region.  This being said, the CTF examined the possibilities of the reality of the situation as presented and charged to them by the Bishop of Manchester.

While “thinking outside the box” was always operative in the collective minds of the task force, having both models of schools (regional and parish) in the cluster as well as a parish served by a religious community made for more focused discernment.  This discernment and discussion resulted in nine possible scenarios that would best suit the needs of the cluster in 2012.  Keen interest in sacramental numbers, financial considerations, proximity, venue, and many practical concerns were examined.  As we reached group consensus that included two basic options (a twinning or merger with Saint Joseph and Mary, Queen of Peace or Saint Joseph and Saint Matthew) it became apparent that the members of the Society of Jesus serving Saint Joseph in Salem would best discern the direction they wanted to embark.  The CTF placed this discernment in their hands and they decided to opt for a twinning with eventual merger of Saint Joseph and Mary, Queen of Peace Parishes.  This rationale is best explained in the words of the Jesuits serving Saint Joseph appearing below in italics:


Decree 2 of the 34th General Congregation of the Society of Jesus tells us that “Today we realize clearly: [that there can be] No service of faith without [the] promotion of justice, entry into cultures, [and] openness to other religious experiences.” (#47). Decree 13 is entitled: Cooperation with the Laity in Mission.  It calls the Society of Jesus to place “itself at the service of this mission of the laity by offering what we are and have received: our spiritual and apostolic inheritance, our educational resources, and our friendship.” (#337).

Mary, Queen of Peace has a similar demographic to St. Joseph Parish, which means that it has a higher percentage of poorer parishioners than St. Matthew Parish. Like St. Joseph, Mary, Queen of Peace Parish creates community across socio-economic boundaries. MQP also has a mixed population with a number of multicultural groups.

Having been without a resident pastor for over a year with only a part-time administrator, lay ministers had to assume a greater responsibility for the parish. Even with the advent of a new pastor, this lay involvement has continued.

Other factors in favor of MQP-St. Joseph merging is the fact that we have some history of working together, not just with Confirmations and with a joint Youth Ministry, but in the past with RCIA and a joint picnic. The building of a high school in Windham and the separation of students from Salem and Windham within three years also argues for linking the two Salem parishes. St. Joseph food pantry mainly serves people from Salem and Methuen and its operation expands on the custom at MQP of giving food baskets at Thanksgiving and Easter.

Because of the history of hurt at MQP in losing a pastor and not having a resident pastor for over a year, it would be helpful to begin the linking of St. Joseph and MQP in Phase I as a twinning with a merger in Phase II while maintaining two worship sites. This will also allow for the continued growth of both parishes and accommodate the spiritual needs of St. Joseph Regional Catholic School.  A transition team must be established to facilitate the movement to the merger of MQP and St. Joseph.  

 

How many pastors are needed to facilitate this recommendation and why?

3 Pastors.

One for Saint Patrick; one for Saint Matthew; one for the twinned and eventually merged Saint Joseph and Mary, Queen of Peace Parishes. 

Our recommendation follows the guidelines as presented by the diocese.

 

How many parochial vicars are needed to facilitate this recommendation and why?

One. 

One full time equivalent parochial vicar for the twinned and eventually merged Saint Joseph – Mary, Queen of Peace Parishes. 

Our recommendation follows the guidelines as presented by the diocese.

 

 

How many deacons are needed to facilitate this recommendation and why?

One sacramental deacon for Saint Patrick Parish.

One full time deacon for Saint Matthew Parish.

Two sacramental deacons for the twinned and eventually merged Saint Joseph and Mary, Queen of Peace Parishes to meet the pastoral and sacramental needs of the cluster.

 

 

 

What type of lay staff are recommended (i.e. administrators, DREs, youth ministers, lay pastoral associates, etc.)

 

            St. Joseph and Mary, Queen of Peace - During the twinning period, it would be important to keep the staffs of the two parishes intact, until it can be determined how best to meld the two parishes. The one difference would be to hire a plant manager-maintenance person. Right now, neither parish has a person with the broad range of skills necessary for the upkeep of an aging physical plant. Thus during the twinning period, MQP would keep its two full-time pastoral associates, its full-time business manager/bookkeeper, its full-time DRE and its secretary. St. Joseph would keep its part-time deacon, its full-time office manager, its part-time secretary, its full-time DRE and part-time religious education secretary, and its part-time youth minister. Both parishes would keep their part-time organists. There would probably be a sharing of a full-time custodian to work with the plant manager. St. Joseph’s would keep its part-time housekeeper and part-time cook.

            By 2012, it would be important to have a sacramental deacon assigned to each church, so that about a third of the baptisms, weddings and funerals could be handled by a deacon. Unfortunately, the trend is for fewer families to request a Mass with a wedding or a funeral. 

St. Patrick staffing and St. Matthew staffing will be determined by pastoral and spiritual needs of each parish.

                                   

 

 

 

Other comments to be brought to the attention of the LRPC and RCBM:

 

Considerations of Deeper Moment for the Ongoing Life of the Church

 

- As Pope John Paul II said in Tertio Millennio Adveniente, “Let us listen to what the faithful say, because in every one of them the Spirit of God breathes.” The following points come from the faithful on the clustering committee and from their pastors.

 

- The Catholic Church is a sacramental Church and the People of God have a right to the Eucharist. “From the liturgy, therefore, and especially from the Eucharist, grace is poured forth upon us as from a fountain, and the sanctification of mankind in Christ and the glorification of God to which all other activities of the Church are directed, as toward their end, are achieved with maximum effectiveness.” Sacrosanctum Concilium, #10.

 

- At the last Synod of Bishops on the Eucharist, various bishops brought forth the proposition that for the Church to continue to grow as the sacramental Church, the Western Church needs to adapt the practice of the Eastern Catholic Churches and ordain men of proven worth to the priesthood. We have already seen such men of proven virtue with the revival of the diaconate in the West.

 

- The diaconate has shown itself of proven worth in many dioceses in the United States. It is important to the Church in the Diocese of Manchester that it have an ongoing program of diaconal formation.

 

-Some ten years ago the Canon Law Society of the United States asked the American bishops to petition the Holy See to revive the Order of Deacons among women. We join our voices and ask that women be ordained to serve as Deacons in the United States. This would revive the practice which goes back to the time of the New Testament and which was seen to be a blessing to the Church in the ministry of such deaconesses as Olympias, the strong supporter of St. John Chrysostom in his exiles. The Rite of Deacon for women has been an ongoing ministry in such Orthodox Churches as the Armenian and has recently been revived among the Greek Orthodox.

- While St. Patrick and St. Matthew are not directly impacted by the twinning\merger process, the task force plans to continue dialogue to foster the good work begun here.

 

Other points of concern:

1.      Rev. Paul Ruzzo’s celebration of his 25th Anniversary in April, 2008

2.      St. Joseph centennial 2010.

-          

 

                                                                        Cluster Task Force 16

 

 

 

 

Report Submitted by:  Paul J. Ashton, Psy.D., D.Min.

 

Facilitator Signature:_______________________________________________________________

 

Date:  10 June 2007

 

                                                                  Cluster Task Force Names and Signatures

NAME (Print)                                                            SIGNATURE

 

Rev. Robert C. Guillemette                          ______________________________

 

Mr. James B. Hogan                                     ______________________________

 

Mrs. M. Gael Ouellette                                ______________________________

 

Rev. Paul F. Ruzzo                                         ______________________________

 

Mrs. Donna Sytek                                         ______________________________

 

Mrs. Mary Giordano                                     ______________________________

 

Rev. John W. Michalowski, S.J.                   ______________________________

 

Mr. Shawn McDonough                                ______________________________

 

Mrs. Claire W. Simensen                              ______________________________

 

Rev. Msgr. Donald Gilbert                           ______________________________

           

Mrs. Ginny Dandreta                                    ______________________________

 

Mrs. Betty Epperson                                     ______________________________

 

Mrs. Joyce Lee (recorder)                            ______________________________